Landmark US Ruling Favors CSX and Norfolk Southern in Car-Storage Fee Dispute

Case background and core finding

The Surface Transportation Board (STB) concluded that the operational control of track, not only the land’s title, determines whether demurrage can apply to privately owned railcars kept on-site. In the Fairless Yard dispute, CSX and Norfolk Southern assessed waiting charges (demurrage) for freight cars left on a siding; Yookel, Inc. and tenant B&J Group argued that those cars sold on privately owned property so demurrage did not attach. The STB framed the issue around who controls and operates the track and whether car storage on that track interferes with other rail operations.

How the Board determined Fairless Yard is railroad operating territory

Conrail moves and holds cars on the roughly 2.7-mile Fairless Branch and uses the track for storing, classifying, and switching cars for multiple customers, not solely for B&J. The STB examined operational facts—who directs movements, who uses the track, and the track’s role in regional service—and found the track functions as part of the shared rail operating system. Because cars remaining past free time on those rails could obstruct other movements and reduce operating capacity, demurrage retained its regulatory purpose.

Why property title alone does not bar demurrage

Ownership of the underlying land (NorthPoint Development acquired the former Fairless Works property in 2020) does not automatically immunize railcars from tariffed waiting charges. The Board separated legal title from operational control: if a railroad (or its agent) operates the track for multiple shippers and the storage risks harming general rail operations, tariff rules and prior notice requirements govern whether demurrage applies. The decision does not declare every privately stored car liable for demurrage in all circumstances; rather it emphasizes specific factors—tariff applicability, proper notice, free time granted, and which railroad controls operations.

Agent relationships, tariff notices, and who must give notice

B&J and Yookel contended Conrail should have issued tariff notices because it physically handled and delivered the cars. The Board found Conrail acted as agent within the shared asset area on behalf of CSX and Norfolk Southern. Under the governing regulatory framework and applicable tariffs (CSX 8100; Norfolk Southern 6004-D), CSX and Norfolk Southern set the relevant rates for traffic they control even where Conrail performs the on-the-ground moves. STB reinforced that advance, effective notice of tariffed charges must exist under 49 CFR 1333.3, but that the operator–agent relationship need not itself be separately restated in the tariff notice to be enforceable.

Link to prior litigation and regulatory framework

The dispute traced back to a 2017 CSX suit against B&J and a 2019 US District Court rulings that CSX awarded a monetary judgment. The STB’s 2014 demurrage liability rule underpins the decision: when an entity accepts cars for loading or unloading after proper tariff notice, it can face liability once free time lapses. The rule aims to limit prolonged dwell in the supply chain and to preserve network fluidity.

Practical effects for logistics parks and private industrial sidings

Facility operators, shippers, and car owners should take three practical steps:

1) Map operational control and use. Document who directs switching, who schedules moves, and which railroads routinely run trains and store cars on-site. That operational map determines whether a track functions as part of the shared rail operating system.

2) Verify tariff notice and free-time terms. Confirm that the applicable railroad tariffs have been published and that customers received proper notice of demurrage rules and free-time allowances. If Conrail or another agent performs moves, verify the principal railroad’s tariff provisions (eg, CSX 8100, NS 6004-D) explicitly cover those arrangements.

3) Contract and site controls to limit exposure. Use lease and service contracts to allocate liability for excess dwell, specify notification flows, and require prompt car removal procedures. Install operational limits—designated storage tracks, maximum on-site dwell durations, and escalation steps to move cars when capacity stress appears.

Examples and a step-by-step checklist to reduce disputes

Example: A developer leases an industrial park and allows multiple tenants to receive railcars. If a tenant does not promptly unload cars, and the park’s track is used by several rail customers, the railroad can assess demurrage once published free time expires—even if the park owner holds the land. Contrast that with a private spur used exclusively by one site and physically isolated from the common operating network; That scenario more readily supports a defense against tariff application.

Checklist:

Step 1: Identify which railroad(s) operate and control the track used for storage. Gather movement records and switching orders.

Step 2: Pull tariffs that could govern the traffic and confirm publication dates and notice procedures.

Step 3: Confirm free time granted for car types in question and document when cars arrived and when unloading began/ended.

Step 4: Update leases to allocate demurrage risk and require immediate notification to the railroad when cars exceed free time.

Step 5: Establish operational triggers to move cars (eg, at 75% of allowable free time) and a plan to resolve disputes quickly (dispute resolution clause, mediation timetable).

What this decision answers in ‘People Also Ask’ style queries

Can a railroad charge demurrage for cars on privately owned land? Yes—if the track is operated as part of the railroad’s shared network (or under its control/agent arrangements) and proper tariff notice and free time rules apply.

Does land ownership always protect a shipper from demurrage? No. Title matters less than operational control, multiple-user access, and whether car storage obstructs other railroad operations.

Who must publish demurrage tariffs when an agent performs switching? The controlling carrier(s) that set rates (here CSX and Norfolk Southern) must have effective tariff notice; the physical performer (Conrail) can function as agent without being the entity that originally published the tariff.

Key takeaways for stakeholders

Operational control and practical use of rails determine demurrage exposure more than simple land ownership. Users of industrial sidings should proactively document control relationships, confirm tariff notice, tighten contract terms, and implement operational protocols to avoid dwell-related charges. The Fairless Yard decision offers a precedent: where private-property sidings serve shared operations, demurrage remains an available regulatory tool to protect network fluidity.